"Vision is bullshit", an eminent Australian politician once famously proclaimed.
Is it ? Some visions became so widely accepted as to determine the behaviour of whole nations or even civilisations. Think Nazi Germany and its lebensraum for Aryans. Think nineteenth century Christianity and its vision of the fate awaiting sinners. And so on.
A vision is a very useful thing to have if you are a strategic planner. Without a sense of where you want to go - or what you want to avoid - you will have some difficulty articulating goals and developing strategies. Negative visions such as a fiery hell, Mutually Assured Destruction or even global warming do tend to be more effective motivators than positive ones.
A few years ago I was involved in a major strategic planning exercise for Sydney which involved many workshops with a wide variety of professional, government, community and industry representatives. It was evident that not everyone shared the same vision ! I jotted down some of the salient points of these different visions, both good and bad. (Bear in mind that this is what people were talking about in 1990, not now).
Being so varied and in some cases incompatible, they are more in the nature of scenarios than visions.
In mid-2000 Sydney endured intense scrutiny by the international media. What vision did they take away? Is your Sydney to be found in the following?
|
THE GREAT AUSTRALIAN DREAM - THEORY
|
THE PLANNER'S VISION - THEORY
|
- Quarter Acre Blocks
- Nuclear Families
- Dog
- Two or More Cars
- Fresh Air & Space
- Beaches & Barbies
- No Worries
- Neighbours
- A Great Place to Raise Kids
|
- Thriving Commercial Centres
- Short Journeys to Work
- New Development Areas
- Universal Public Transport
- Distributed Social Services
- Isolated Heavy Industry
- Nature Parks
- High Densities Along Transit Corridors
- Equity
|
|
TECHNOPOLIS
|
THE FUNDAMENTAL CITY
|
- Rampant Telematics
- High-Tech Industries
- Investment in Higher Education
- University of the Pacific Rim
- Home Work, Telecommuting, Televillages
- Smart Vehicles, Smart Roads
- Automated Public Transport
- Dial-a-Ride
- Silicon Creek : Canberra-Sydney-Newcastle
- Leading Edge Environmental Protection
- Leading Edge Recycling Industry
- Robotics in Manufacturing
- Energy Efficiency
- Dual Water Supply
|
- Sustainability (social, environmental and financial)
- Human-ness
- Economic Development
- Equity
- Robustness in Respect to Future Change
|
|
THE GREEN CITY
|
THE PRODUCTIVE CITY
|
- Trees
- Clean Water, Clean Air
- Bicycles
- Pavement Cafes
- Grow Your Own Veg
- Sustainable Development
- Clean Car Engines
- Solar Power
- Light Rail, Gas-Driven Buses
- Road-Rail Freight Interchanges
- Disappearance of Smokestack Industry
- Individual Responsibility
- Biodiversity
- Intergenerational equity
- Ecocentric ethic
|
- Centre for Pacific Trade and Commerce, Freight Movement a Priority, Result-Oriented Workforce, Efficient Use of Resources, 24-Hour Transport Networks, Satellite Monitoring of Freight, Import Substitution
- Abolition of Restrictive Practices, Enterprise Bargaining, Lean Mean Waterfront and Freight Interchanges, Flexitime
- Post-Extractive Processing Industries, Bush-City Economic Integration, Good Port & Airport Access, Bulk Exported in Australian Bottoms
- Commercial Legal and Administrative Services, Universal EDI, Integration with Asia
- World Class Tourism Development/Marketing, Recreation and Sport Industries, Olympic Village, Effective Public Transport Hierarchy
|
|
THE PRIVATISED CITY
|
THE CONTAINED CITY
|
- User Pays
- Deregulation
- Large-Scale Integrated Urban Developments
- Competitive Marketing By Developers
- Pacific Headquarters of Multinationals
- Disposal or Corporatisation of Government Enterprises
- Reduction of All Tiers of Government
- Red Tape Purge
- Transparency in CSO's
|
- Super-CBD from Mascot to Gordon
- Western Sydney a Dormitory Area
- Fewer Suburban Stations, Faster Trains
- Long-Distance Commuting from beyond Cumberland Plain
- Centralisation of Social and Cultural Facilities
- Western Sydney Greenfield Development Taboo
- High Density Development Around Harbour
- Intensification of Middle Sydney Around Transport Corridors
- Increase in Dual Occupancy
- Greater Social Variegation
- Regeneration of Inner Areas
|
|
THE GREAT AUSTRALIAN DREAM - PRACTICE
|
THE PLANNER'S VISION - PRACTICE
|
- Long Journeys to Work
- Road Congestion
- Rail Overcrowding
- Absence of Effective Local Public Transport
- Latch-Key Children
- Social Tension
- Quality Differentials Escalate
- Punitive Mortgages
- Central Employers Unable to Staff Businesses
- Deteriorating Air and Water Quality
- Severance of Neighbourhoods by Traffic
- Blight
- Immigrant Ghettos
- Outer Area Social/Cultural Deprivation
|
- Deficient Infrastructure Perpetuates Pattern
- No Circuit-Breakers
- Inappropriate Institutional Structures
- High Operating Subsidy
- Local-Central Government Contention
- No Incentives for Employers to Expand/Relocate
- Concentration on CBD
- Workers Disenfranchised from Public Transport
- Absence of Strategic Planning
- Efficiency not Effectiveness
- Electoral Cycles Cripple Policy Consistency
- Red Tape, Kerb and Gutter Issues, Pork-Barrelling, Ratbaggery
|
|
FADED GLORY
|
THE REGULATED CITY
|
- Lack of Appropriate Skills in Workforce
- Flight by Employers
- Exodus to Queensland
- Suburbs of Couch Potatoes
- Urban Decay
- Hand-to-Mouth Small Businesses
- Protected Industry
- High Living Costs
- Poor Quality
- Chip on Shoulder
- Resentment of Immigrants
- Loss of Sea Trade to Queensland/Land Bridge
- Collapse of Tourist Trade
|
- Strong Government Control
- Council Powers on Zoning Taken Over By State
- New Council Powers Invented
- Restrictions on Car Use and Parking
- Australia Card
- Doublethink and Political Correctness
- Proliferation of Police and Quasi-Police
- Docile Population (Singapore Model) ...
- or Official Corruption, Double Standards, Black Economy (Soviet/African Model)
|
|
THE THIRD-WORLD CITY
|
THE DIVIDED CITY
|
- Inability to Pay for Quality Imports
- Makeshift Local Products
- Dominance by Entrepreneurial Immigrants
- Population Numbers Swamp Infrastructure
- Declining Health and Education Standards
- Teeming Millions
- Shack Cities
- Growth of Superstition
|
- Accentuated Divisions and Tension Between Rich and Poor
- Low Income Ghettoes
- Filth
- Crime
- Drugs
- Harbour/North Shore an Enclave for the Rich
- Booming Security Industry
- Walled Residential Development
- Gun Ownership Increase
- Strains Within Lower Ranks
- Declining Work Opportunities for Poor
- Declining Security and Standards for Rich
- Return of Servants
- Street Kids
|
|
NATURE'S REVENGE
|
- Fouled Waterways
- Toxic Air
- Insect-Borne Plague
- Soil Degradation
- Ozone Hole
- Carcinogenic Sunshine
- Blue-Green Algae
- Rising Sea Level
- Accumulated Rubbish
- Choking
- Poisoning
- Mutation
- Extinction of Intelligence
- World Inherited by Cockroaches
|
 
|
While there are some bits of most of the preceding to be found, I think most people's verdict would be the same as mine - pretty bloody good.